Anybody from Meriden, CT will tell you this is hands-down, the best pizza you can find in the whole state! I found that to be a bit exaggerated, considering Connecticut is home to a place called Wooster Street, New Haven.
Ah, what the hell, I thought to myself. Let me try this place. I'm sick of the mean waitresses and hour-long waits in New Haven, anyways... and The Little Rendezvous has a 124 year old brick oven!!
I think the first night I wanted to try it was a Tuesday. Closed Tuesdays. Strange day for a pizza place to be closed. Not off to a good start. So I waited until Friday came. It was a 45 minute wait for a mozzarella pizza pick-up (did I mention they don't deliver?). On the weekends you can wait even longer for pizza- I was lucky! The staff gets as big as three people, so it's hard for them to keep up with the weekend demand. And you can certainly hear it in their voices when they're overworked and stressed, though they are typically friendly. Once I called and got the "it'll be a 2 hour wait", said with a bit of an attitude. Seriously? It's like they didn't want me to order their pizza! Hire an extra person for the weekends, already! Needless to say, I wasn't going to wait 2 hours for a pizza when I live in a state filled with great pizza everywhere! Among other things - it's cash only, located in the ghetto with on-street parking only, and they only sell whole pizzas, no slices, no calzones, no antipasto, just....entire pizza pies.
So let me tell you about this pizza. Now, since my first time eating this, I have eaten quite a few of Rendezvous pizzas. They're not always consistent, but the pizza goes down nicely. The toppings are delicious- they typically are the same, I find- not too overdone, the cheese is lightly sprinkled on, seasonings aren't overbearing, they are just right. But the crust.... many times I have eaten pizza from here, the crust has been tough and way too chewy, to the point where it is hard to cut with a dinner knife. They tell you on their website that their pizza is crispy and "singed on the edges", which sounds to me like you could break it with your bare hands like bark from a tree, no?
This particular pizza that I recently ate ( as pictured) was nicely crisp, one of their best pizzas I've had in a while. As I said, they're inconsistent, as most pizza places are. But are they just as good as all those famous New Haven pizza restaurants? Yeah, I'd say so. Just make sure you can drive and get the pizza yourself. And have cash. And it's not Monday or Tuesday.
PROS :
-Pizza from a very old brick oven!!! Yum!!
-They offer wheat crust as well as gluten-free crust
-They sell beer
-You don't have to deal with the New Haven pizza nonsense!
-They have seating if you'd like to eat it there.
CONS :
-Cash only (not good for a credit lover such as myself)
-Located in a bad neighborhood
-Funky hours
-Long waits on the weekends
-Pizza crust can be tough/chewy at times
-The only food they sell here is whole pizzas!
Due to a decent amount of "cons", despite it being a tasty pizza I have to give them:
3 out of 5 stars